Dual 1.8 G5 Firewire toast

1 reply [Last post]
Offline
Joined: Jan 18 2007
Posts: 1

Hi all,

I hope this is the right place... Someone pointed me here for another issue I'll address in a seperate post and it seems like there's much more knowledge than other "have you repaired permissions?" forums.

I have a dual 1.8 G5 that besides having the annoying power supply "chirp" noise has an issue with the onboard Firewire. One day after not using anything Firewire for a few months I went to plug in my DV camera and it wasn't recognized. Nor was a hard drive in a FW enclosure. Looking at System Profiler, the Firewire pane was just empty. Did a PRAM reset, booted to a clean install on another partition, nada. Hardware test CD dumps core when hitting the Firewire stuff. Machine no longer sleeps as it's likely trying to do something with the FW ports before going to sleep.

On boot, there's this message:

Jan 11 22:43:34 localhost kernel: FWOHCI Error trying to clear PHY ports.

Lots of talk on Apple's boards about dead FW ports. A new logic board doesn't make financial sense on this machine unless I could get one cheap.

I recently put a cheap IOGear FW card in and it works. However now instead of just showing nothing under Firewire in SystemProfiler, it crashes, as does the cli version (system_profiler) with a "bus error". In turn, that causes CrashReporter to crash as well since it calls system_profiler to get info on the machine. Whee!

Now the questions:

-Any chance of finding a cheap logic board? Ideally I'd like to sell this thing off and just go to an intel iMac. I can't sell it in it's current state.
-Is there any chance of "fixing" the onboard FW? Or anyone that does work on logic boards?
-Is there any way in OpenFirmware to fully disable the onboard Firewire?

The last one would be a good fix for me. If the OS never saw the broken onboard Firewire, I bet the machine would sleep again. It may also fix the system profiler crash, who knows. In the past I've had trouble finding good docs on OF. Perhaps there's an OF guru here?

Thanks!

Charles

ps - nice forum software!

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Jon's picture
Jon
Offline
Joined: Dec 20 2003
Posts: 2804
It may be possible to disconn

It may be possible to disconnect/lift the power pin of the FW controller if there's no OF fix. I don't know if it will cause the machine to not boot, but it would only be one/a few pin(s) to reconnect if it does.

__________________

I am not in this world to live up to other people's expectations, nor do I feel that the world must live up to mine. - Fritz Perls